Controlling Restart Manager behaviour

I've heard that there may be a bug in this area, but that's just rumor. The
behavior is that only the first row in the ServiceControl table is
inspected, so RM doesn't know that the service will be stopped. Does that
look relevant here?
--
Phil Wilson
The Definitive Guide to Windows Installer
http://www.apress.com/book/view/1590592972


"Nick Hall" <NickHall@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:46A38841-2528-4C62-9DBE-5FF59440F3BB@microsoft.com...
> Our application installs a Microsoft Exchange agent (Exchange 2007,
> Windows
> Server 2008) using a Wix-authored MSI. The dll gets loaded by the
> Exchange
> Transport Service. I've added a ServiceControl element to stop and start
> the
> service which seems to work OK. The problem is that when the application
> is
> being uninstalled I get a dialog telling me that a reboot will be
> required.
> If I OK this, the uninstall functions correctly without the reboot (as by
> the
> time the files are uninstalled the service has been stopped).
>
> I believe that the problem is due to the way that the Exchange service is
> implemented. The service executable is called MSExchangeTransport.exe
> which
> then uses a process called EdgeTransport.exe to host our dll. Because the
> dll is not being hosted directly by the service, Restart Manager is not
> correctly recognizing that there is not a problem.
>
> This is the contents of the uninstall log pertaining to the reboot
> request: -
>
> MSI (s) (78:0C) [18:28:22:904]: RESTART MANAGER: Did detect that a
> critical
> application holds file[s] in use, so a reboot will be necessary.
> MSI (s) (78:0C) [18:28:22:904]: Note: 1: 1610 MSI (s) (78:0C)
> [18:29:08:864]: RESTART MANAGER: The user chose to go on with the
> installation, although a reboot will be required.
>
> Is there any way, using a custom action or via another method that I can
> somehow let Restart Manager know the dlls held by EdgeTransport should not
> prevent uninstall (as the process will be terminated when its parent
> service
> shuts down)?
>
> Thanks,
>
> Nick Hall
>

Our application installs a Microsoft Exchange agent (Exchange 2007, Windows
Server 2008) using a Wix-authored MSI. The dll gets loaded by the Exchange
Transport Service. I've added a ServiceControl element to stop and start the
service which seems to work OK. The problem is that when the application is
being uninstalled I get a dialog telling me that a reboot will be required.
If I OK this, the uninstall functions correctly without the reboot (as by the
time the files are uninstalled the service has been stopped).

I believe that the problem is due to the way that the Exchange service is
implemented. The service executable is called MSExchangeTransport.exe which
then uses a process called EdgeTransport.exe to host our dll. Because the
dll is not being hosted directly by the service, Restart Manager is not
correctly recognizing that there is not a problem.

This is the contents of the uninstall log pertaining to the reboot request: -

MSI (s) (78:0C) [18:28:22:904]: RESTART MANAGER: Did detect that a critical
application holds file[s] in use, so a reboot will be necessary.
MSI (s) (78:0C) [18:28:22:904]: Note: 1: 1610 MSI (s) (78:0C)
[18:29:08:864]: RESTART MANAGER: The user chose to go on with the
installation, although a reboot will be required.

Is there any way, using a custom action or via another method that I can
somehow let Restart Manager know the dlls held by EdgeTransport should not
prevent uninstall (as the process will be terminated when its parent service
shuts down)?

Thanks,

Nick Hall

NH> Is there any way, using a custom action or via another method that I
NH> can somehow let Restart Manager know the dlls held by EdgeTransport
NH> should not prevent uninstall (as the process will be terminated when
NH> its parent service shuts down)?

If this is happening in the execute sequence, can you stop the service
before RM has looked?

Vadim Rapp